Thursday night features a full slate of NHL action, and we have isolated three spots for our best NHL shutout props based on recent form and historical perspectives. Let’s delve into these games to find the goalies most likely to lower their goals against average and record a shutout.
NHL Shutout Goalie Odds for Today
One of the first elements of our NHL shutout props analysis involves reviewing the totals for each game. The lower the total, the less likely there will be considerable scoring. After that, we find out which goalies are starting and how they have performed recently and historically against their opponents.
With that said, below are our best NHL shutout props.
| Goalie | Team | Opponent | SO Odds | Pick | Sportsbook |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jake Oettinger | Dallas Stars | Canucks | +1200 | Shutout | BetMGM |
| Stuart Skinner | Edmonton Oilers | Islanders | +1235 | Shutout | Caesars |
| Jeremy Swayman | Boston Bruins | Golden Knights | +1425 | Shutout | BetMGM |
Best Shutout Prop Picks Today
Stuart Skinner Shutout (+1235) at Caesars
Oilers vs. Islanders – October 16, 2025, 7:30 PM EDT
The Edmonton Oilers, a team known for its explosive offense, sit with the lowest goals against in the league after three games. The Oilers’ goaltending tandem of Calvin Pickard and Stuart Skinner has allowed just five goals thus far, and we will likely see Stuart Skinner tending the twine tonight.
On Tuesday night, Skinner blanked the Rangers in a 2-0 victory, and he won’t have to go far to do it again as he suits up against another New York team, the Islanders, who are dead last in goals with only seven over their first three games.
Let’s watch Skinner get back-to-back shutouts on Thursday night!
Jake Oettinger Shutout (+1200) at BetMGM
Canucks vs. Stars – October 16, 2025, 8:00 PM EDT
The Dallas Stars have been doing nothing but winning since the preseason, winning five of six during the exhibition season, and are now perched near the top of the Central Division with a perfect 3-0 regular season record.
Therefore, it is not surprising that the Stars are big home favorites over the 1-2 Vancouver Canucks. Dallas goalie Jake Oettinger has started in all three wins and is likely to go tonight against a much lower caliber of opponent than he has faced in beating Winnipeg, Colorado, and Minnesota.
The Canucks have only tallied eight goals over three games, ranking them 31st among 32 teams in scoring. This should be a walk in the park for Oettinger, which is why we will happily take the +1200 NHL odds that BetMGM is giving us for him to register a shutout.
Sleeper Shutout Picks
Jeremy Swayman Shutout (+1425) at BetMGM
Bruins vs. Golden Knights – October 16, 2025, 10:00 PM EDT
Jeremy Swayman of the Boston Bruins is coming off a disappointing year in which contract squabbles kept him off the ice for the beginning of the season, and once he got the bag, he never got on track.
However, he has looked much better this season and will likely be getting his turn to suit up after alternating the first four games with platoonmate Joonas Korpisalo. Swayman has allowed just two goals over his two appearances, both 3-1 victories, and will face a Golden Knights team that is coming off a 4-2 win over the Flames.
I believe Swayman will shine in the net tonight, just as he has done in his first two games. Let’s take a flier on Swayman because the price is nice at BetMGM.
Place Your Shutout Prop Bets Now
Now that we have listed our goalie shutout best bets and their corresponding NHL goalie shutout odds, we must make sure that we have accounts at two or more of the best US-licensed sportsbooks like Caesars and BetMGM. This way, we can compare numbers and take advantage of the best odds available, all listed right here at OddsTrader.
Remember, the lines and odds don’t stay stagnant. They move, so why not get down on these NHL shutout props when the getting is good? Lock in on a line, and you’ll never have to worry that you missed out on value. Check out what the best sportsbooks in the nation are dealing on these goalies and put your bets in right now!
Include OddsTrader Turbo as One of Your Betting Tools
Stop guessing and start winning with OddsTrader Turbo. This is like having a personal assistant, available 24/7, for only a few dollars each month. Harness the power of artificial intelligence and let OddsTrader Turbo do all the heavy lifting as a bet analyzer tailored to your needs.
Below are just a few features:
- 5-star picks with a 73% accuracy rating
- Exclusive BetStation chatbot for expert advice, betting tips, and AI-powered insight
- Sportsbook syncing to keep track of all your bets across all your sportsbook accounts in one place
- Game alerts
- Real-time line movement updates
- 5 Star AI picks
Start a free 30-day trial and ask BetStation questions regarding the games mentioned above. It’s all right here at OddsTrader. If you try it once, you’ll never gamble again without it!
*21+ Seek help with a gambling addiction at 1-800-GAMBLER
*The line and/or odds referenced in this article might have changed since the content was published. For the latest information on line movements, visit OddsTrader’s free betting odds tool.
