Pittsburgh Penguins vs Toronto Maple Leafs Betting Trends

The upcoming NHL showdown on December 23, 2025, features the Pittsburgh Penguins visiting the Toronto Maple Leafs at Scotiabank Arena in Toronto, ON. This regular-season game promises exciting betting trends as the Maple Leafs, currently favored at -135 moneyline odds, aim to leverage their strong powerplay percentage of 25.7% against the Penguins' 28%. Both teams show competitive penalty kill stats, with Toronto at 76.6% and Pittsburgh slightly better at 80.0%, adding a strategic edge to the matchup. The 5-on-5 play sees Toronto at 57% faceoff wins, which could be crucial in controlling the game's pace.

Starting goalies are expected to be healthy, with no major injury concerns reported, making this a true test of skill and strategy. The total points line is set at 6 with an over favorite at -115, reflecting the recent high-scoring trends between these teams. Bettors should consider the recent 7-2 victory by Toronto over Pittsburgh on November 29, which showcased Toronto’s offensive prowess and might influence the psychological edge heading into this game.

The Penguins hold a respectable away ATS record of 12-5, while the Maple Leafs have struggled against the spread at home with an 8-12 record. These betting stats and game insights provide valuable information for making smart wagers. Fans can catch the game on TNT, truTV, and HBO Max. Ready to bet smarter? Start your OddsTrader Turbo subscription now or place your bet with a U.S. regulated sportsbook and profit off the edge.