New York Islanders vs Calgary Flames Betting Trends

The upcoming NHL regular season game on January 17, 2026, between the New York Islanders and Calgary Flames at Scotiabank Saddledome in Calgary, AB, CAN, promises an exciting showdown. The Calgary Flames, known for their strong home performances with a 12-9 record and an impressive 15-6 ATS home record, will face off against the New York Islanders, who hold a solid 12-11 record on the road and a 16-7 ATS away record. This matchup offers valuable betting insights for enthusiasts looking to capitalize on the action.

The starting goalies are expected to be consistent with recent lineups, with no significant injuries reported that could impact the game. Both teams have competitive powerplay percentages, with Calgary at 13% and the Islanders close behind at 8.47%, while penalty kill percentages and 5-on-5 stats also reflect tight defensive play. Calgary averages 2.55 goals per game with a shooting percentage that complements their aggressive offense, whereas the Islanders average 2.87 goals per game, showing slightly higher offensive output.

The odds favor the New York Islanders as slight favorites at -113, with Calgary Flames at -101. The puck line is set at -1.5 for the Islanders at +222 and +1.5 for Calgary at -270, indicating bettors can find value in the Flames covering the spread. The total points line is set at 5.5, with an over favorite at -120, suggesting expectations for a moderately high-scoring game. These betting trends, combined with the teams' recent form and venue advantage, provide a comprehensive view to make smart wagering decisions. For a deeper dive into the teams' dynamics, check out the last matchup on March 22, 2025, where Calgary edged out the Islanders 4-3 in a thrilling contest.