Colorado Avalanche vs Toronto Maple Leafs Picks

The Colorado Avalanche face off against the Toronto Maple Leafs on January 25, 2026, at Scotiabank Arena in Toronto, ON. This NHL matchup promises intense hockey action as these two teams battle it out in a regular season game. Our picks highlight a predicted close contest with Colorado edging Toronto 4-3, backed by a slight moneyline advantage for the Avalanche.

Analyzing key stats, Colorado holds a powerplay percentage of 62.4%, surpassing Toronto's 37.6%, indicating a more potent offensive threat during man-advantage situations. However, Toronto's penalty kill percentage is slightly better, suggesting their defense can mitigate Colorado's powerplays effectively. Both teams have comparable 5-on-5 percentages, implying balanced play during even strength. These factors are crucial for bettors seeking to make informed bets on powerplay and penalty kill markets.

Our prediction model has been profitable over the past 10 NHL games, boasting a hit rate above 60% on 2-way markets including overtime and penalties, with a positive EV of around -0.4% for Colorado and -0.9% for Toronto. This track record supports confidence in our picks and betting tips for this game. Fans can catch the action live on NHL Network and ESPN+.

For detailed analysis and further NHL picks, visit our NHL picks and predictions page. Also, discover the best sportsbooks to place your wagers safely and confidently with our expert reviews.