Betting Trends Columbus Blue Jackets vs N.Y. Islanders

The NHL showdown between the Columbus Blue Jackets and the New York Islanders is set for December 28, 2025, at Nationwide Arena in Columbus, OH. This game offers exciting betting trends to watch as both teams bring contrasting strengths to the ice. Columbus boasts a strong powerplay percentage, converting on approximately 25.6% of opportunities, while the Islanders hold a slight edge in penalty kill percentage at 81.2%. Both teams hover around a solid 5-on-5 percentage, with Columbus slightly ahead. The Islanders will likely start their top goalie, who has been consistent this season, while Columbus’s starter is questionable but expected to play, adding an intriguing layer to betting insights.

The odds favor Columbus with a -140 moneyline and a -1.5 point spread at +180, while the Islanders offer +118 moneyline odds and a +1.5 spread at -220. The total points line is set at 5.5, with the over favored at -130. These betting stats suggest a competitive game where the underdog Islanders could cover the spread if they capitalize on their penalty kill strengths. The last matchup on November 2, 2025, saw the Islanders narrowly win 3-2, a game that bettors should reference for trends and player performances.

Columbus’s recent form includes a strong showing with a 3-1 win over the Los Angeles Kings, while the Islanders have been solid with wins like their 2-0 victory against the New York Rangers. Both teams have mixed records against the spread, but the Islanders have a better away ATS record, which could influence bets. The game will be broadcast on ESPN+, MSGSN, and FDSOH, making it easy for fans to catch the action. For those looking to leverage these insights for smarter bets, Start your OddsTrader Turbo subscription or place a wager with a U.S. regulated sportsbook to gain the edge.