New York Rangers vs Toronto Maple Leafs Betting Trends

On October 16, 2025, the New York Rangers face the Toronto Maple Leafs at Scotiabank Arena in Toronto, ON. This NHL matchup will air on MSG and ESPN+. Starting goalies are Igor Shesterkin for New York and Ilya Samsonov for Toronto, with both teams entering healthy and ready for a classic battle.

Offensively, the Rangers average 2.0 goals on 30.6 shots per game (shooting 6.5%), while the Maple Leafs lead the league at 4.25 goals on 29.5 shots (14.4%). Defensively, New York allows just 0.8 goals per contest, and Toronto concedes 3.25, making goaltending a pivotal factor in these betting trends.

Special teams and possession metrics underline contrasting styles. Toronto logs 2.0 power plays and 7.5 penalty minutes per game, while New York sits at 2.8 power plays with 4.4 penalty minutes. At 5-on-5, the Rangers play a contained approach, whereas the Maple Leafs push a higher tempo and scoring volume.

Faceoffs and physicality will also matter. The Rangers win 55.4% of draws, and the Maple Leafs sit at 55%, pointing to tight puck battles. Blocked shots (14.4 by New York, 15.75 by Toronto) and giveaways are key indicators for those seeking deeper game insights.

In their last matchup, on March 20, 2025, the Maple Leafs defeated the Rangers 4-3. New York is 2-0 on the road ATS, and Toronto is 2-1 at home, as shown on our NHL standings page.

The best moneyline odds favor Toronto at -145 with Caesars, compared to +122 for New York at Caesars. Back the Toronto Maple Leafs on the moneyline at -145 with Caesars. Use these betting stats to inform your smart wager. Ready to gain more edge? Start your OddsTrader Turbo subscription or place your bet with a U.S. regulated sportsbook now.